General CBF

A Declining Church

The following post is from Nathan Dean, CBF church starter and pastor of Edgewood Church in Atlanta. This blog was written for the churchworks! e-newsletter. You can subscribe to one of our many e-newsletters here.

Carrie and NathanI received an email the other day from a wonderful Christian woman who is concerned for her church.  Her church is steadily declining.  This isn’t an unusual situation.  Approximately 90% of the churches in the United States are plateaued or declining. She is on a committee that is trying to figure out how to reach out to their neighbors and stop the decline and asked us for ideas on what to do.

Since this almost certainly is or will be an issue for your church, I thought I’d share my advice with you.  For whatever it is worth, here it is: 

  • Lose any agenda you have to grow your church – People can sense an agenda a mile away.  Your church will grow as a byproduct of it being the presence of Christ in its community.  People long to be loved without an agenda.  They will sense this when they interact with you in the community and even when they walk through your church doors.  You will find your life, organizationally and spiritually, by losing it. A great mindset to take on is, “If this is the last year God allows my church to exist in this community, I want people here to know that there were Christians here who loved them.  I want them to mourn its passing.”
  • Trade the Us-Them paradigm for an Us-For-Them Paradigm – Paradigms grow from an individual, to a group, to the organization.  Find ways to get to know and love the people in your community, in your parish, like they were your church family, your real family. A great quote from William Temple says, “Christianity is the only co-operative society that exists for the benefit of non-members.”
  • Minister to the broken places and the stretched places in your community and in people’s lives – The places where people and communities are hurting or stressed are the places where they can best see God and their need for God.  Find out when people are having babies, moving, lose their jobs, go to the hospital, lose their home, etc.  Seek out places that need justice, peace, racial reconciliation, hope, etc.  Seek out community organizations that are working for hope, peace, building community, etc. (schools, police departments, fire departments, non-profits, etc) and find ways to support and bless them.  When we went into the schools we would tell them with all sincerity that “Whether you believe it or not, we believe that when you are working to give children hope and a future, that you are doing God’s work, and we want to bless and support you however we can.” You may not meet all the needs of your community directly, you can’t and that isn’t even the best solution most of the time.  You may often find yourself connecting community needs with community assets.  You may find yourself being a relationship and resource broker for your community and your church.  Be the leaven in bread, the salt in the flavor of your community.
  • Make a List of Community Leaders – Police and firefighting major and captains, principals, organizational leaders, council members, etc. and make friends with them. Get their cell phone numbers in your phone.  Get their email addresses.  Take them out to lunch every now and then.  Check in on them from time to time to see how things are going with them personally and with their organization.  Take them cookies or special coffees. Offer to pray with them and for them.  Offer to help them however you and your church can.  Don’t worry about having major moments or breakthroughs with them.  Those will come in time, maybe a lot of time, but they will come.  Just be consistent.
  • Listen to Carrie’s Sermon – On April 21st Carrie preached a sermon called “Someone to Follow.”  She gave great practical advice there on how to disciple people who are not Christians. Click here to listen.
  • Be Patient – Change takes tons of effort and tons of time.  I am still overwhelmed by the reality of this truth many days, but change does happen.  I have to remind myself to not be any more impatient than God is.
  • PrayWhen it is all said and done, on our best days, we are only participants with God in what God is doing in the world. It is God and only God, that really changes people’s lives and changes communities from the inside out, one person at a time.

I hope this helps.  Helping the church be who God has called and empowered it to be is near and dear to our hearts.  Emails and conversations on the topic are always welcome.

7 thoughts on “A Declining Church

  1. One of the VERY best articles I’ve ever read on helping a church or a minister understand church change.

  2. Pingback: A Declining Church | Cooperative Baptist Fellowship Blog | Church Growth

  3. You have some great ideas. I agree that reaching out to the lost is important. But where does preaching the Gospel fit in? Without doing that, what is the point?

  4. Hi Mary,

    Great Question.

    The Gospel is preached explicitly and implicitly in everything we do – that is the goal anyway. We do our best to live out the Gospel before others, to speak the Gospel into situations and circumstances of our community and the lives of individuals, and we pray for the Gospel to take root in people’s lives and in our community.

    Another place that we explicitly preach the Gospel is in church on Sunday mornings. Not everyone in our church on Sunday mornings are Christians, and certainly everyone is not coming from a Christian worldview. If you would like more information on how we very intentionally use the gift of people’s time and attention on Sunday mornings to communicate the Gospel and mature disciples, just send me an email sometime.

    Quite a lot can be said and discussed about where preaching the Gospel fits in to our life as Christians. If you’d like to talk about this more, please contact me. I would enjoy the conversation.

    How do you preach, share, and live out the Gospel in your context?

    Nathan

    PS – I wrote and article for CBF about evangelism a little while back. Here is the link:
    http://cbfportal.wordpress.com/2012/05/25/the-only-thing-that-really-matters/

    • Well goodness. I posted a response earlier, but don’t see it here. My aplogies if this turns out to be a duplicate. I think we should be clear on what the Gospel is. Is it not something we do, rather it is something we proclaim. We are not living it, rather Christ already accomplished it on the cross. The Gospel is the good news of God’s sinless son willingly offering to suffer under God’s wrath as the perfect sacrifice. His righteousness is imputed into those who repent and trust in Him. And we are saved through faith alone in Christ alone. That is good news to proclaim! Now that does not mean that we should not love and serve others, for God’s glory. But that is not the Gospel. That is the Law, and we should not confuse the two. We cannot follow the Law perfectly, so telling people that the Gospel is doing and living things is actually condeming them. We cannot possibly achieve a perfect following of the Law, and that is exactly why we need the Gospel! So, how does the Gospel affect me? God has graciously loved and forgiven me, an undeserving sinner. So, I should love and forgive others, as the Law commands. But simply serving others without preaching the Gospel is faulty. We should feed the hungry and comfort the lonely and sick. But they must also hear the Good News of salvation.

  5. I read this article and was so impressed I shared it with the Board of Deacons. I think it articulated quite well the good news is expressed in the community. We too take the words of Jesus quite seriously. To confine the preaching of the gospel to merely the vocalization of the salvation message is to entirely miss the point of the gospel. It is what we do and who we are (see what Jesus said in Matthew 25 for more information on this).
    The fact remains that churches are declining and unless we get back to the very basics of the gospel as Nathan is expressing through his ministry the decline will continue. It frustrates me when I read responses to this such as I have here that bisect the gospel into two separate things. I do not believe the original blog excluded verbalizing the gospel in any way, but indicated that it must certainly be lived before others too.

  6. Pingback: They’re Concerned… | Pastor Kemp's Blog

Leave a Reply