racial justice / Racial Reconciliation / Robert Jones

Arthur Ashe versus the Confederacy

With removal of Robert E. Lee statue, the Arthur Ashe Jr. memorial stands alone on Richmond’s Monument Avenue

By Robert P. Jones

The news broke this week that the Virginia Supreme Court has cleared the state to remove the last Confederate monument still standing on the city’s Monument Avenue, the massive tribute to General Robert E. Lee.

A 21-foot bronze sculpture mounted on a massive 40-foot pedestal, it was primarily funded and conceived by the Ladies’ Lee Monument Committee, a predecessor to the United Daughters of the Confederacy (UDC), which has its headquarters in Richmond to this day. Its dedication on May 29, 1890, was accompanied by three days of events (including a choral performance by the Young Men’s Christian Association) that drew an estimated 100,000 people. Beside the statue, special stands were constructed to contain hundreds of white children wearing red, white, and blue who were arranged to create a living Confederate battle flag.

Example of churches surrounding traffic circle for Confederate monuments. J.E.B. Stuart Monument pedestal (statue removed 2020), Monument Avenue, Richmond, VA.

The title of the Richmond Times editorial that week captured how Richmond’s white residents understood the meaning of this new landmark: “Conquered Though Not Vanquished.” As historian Karen Cox summarized it, “This was not just a monument to the region’s most cherished hero; it was about the restoration of Confederate men’s honor.”1 It was also a declaration of a war on the terrain of culture and politics as Virginia, like many southern states, were throwing off the reforms of Reconstruction and setting up legal and cultural systems of segregation and the suppression of voting by African Americans.

Cover of local paper covering Arthur Ashe exhibit at VMHC, Richmond, VA, 2019.

The Lee monument was the downpayment by the city’s white elite on a multi-decade effort to create the broad leafy outdoor corridor that would eventually be punctuated by five traffic circles, each containing a massive monument to the Confederacy.2 Between 1890 and 1930, the wealthier white population not only moved their homes but also rebuilt at least seven of their churches out along Monument Avenue in the shadow of these monuments. The architectural interplay between monuments dedicated to the Confederacy and sanctuaries dedicated to God performatively expressed the motto emblazoned on the five-story column behind the statue of Jefferson Davis: “God will vindicate.”

Over the past few years, I’ve spent several weeks in Richmond, conducting research in the archives of the UDC for White Too Long and tracking the unfolding drama as the city and its churches are attempting to extricate themselves from the Lost Cause narrative and create a new story that looks to the future, rather than the past. The juxtapositions, and contradictions, can be jarring.

Monument to Arthur Ashe Jr., Monument Avenue, Richmond, VA (rear view).
  • When I first visited in July 2019, the city had just renamed one of its central streets—one that historically fronted the national headquarters of the UDC along with “Battle Abbey,” originally built to hold Confederate reliquary and now the Virginia Museum of History and Culture—after native son and international tennis star Arthur Ashe Jr.3 As a youth, Ashe had been banned from playing tennis on Richmond’s public courts because of his race. As an adult, he dedicated his life off the court to international civil rights work, philanthropy, and scholarship.
  • That summer, the VMHC had hung large banners of Ashe outside the building, and there were images of him on large placards along the sidewalk. Just 30 feet or so down the sidewalk in front of the UDC building, half a dozen pro-Confederate protesters had hoisted large Confederate Battle Flags on makeshift poles over placards that read, “Save our monuments.”
  • When the UDC archivist handed me her business card, it had already been updated to show their location on “Arthur Ashe Boulevard.”

Interestingly, this is not the first time that Richmond’s residents have called on Ashe to oppose Confederate forces in Richmond. In 1996, three years after his untimely death, the city placed a memorial to Ashe on Monument Avenue. The twelve foot tall statue, sitting on a 21-foot pedestal, sits on a traffic circle just beyond the last of five Confederate monuments along the venue. About 500 people attended the unveiling of the monument, with some holding up Confederate flags in protest.

Monument to Robert E. Lee, Monument Avenue, Richmond, VA (after 2020 Black Lives Matter protests).

When I visited in 2019, I was struck by how diminutive Ashe seemed in the context of Monument Avenue. His likeness, anchoring one end of the avenue, was roughly half the size of the Lee, Davis, and Jackson monuments nearer the city center. But when I revisited Monument Avenue over this past summer, the statue of Ashe, with a book held high in his right hand and a tennis racket slightly lower in his left (a pose explicitly requested by Ashe himself to emphasize the importance of education) loomed larger.

Four of the five Confederate statues were removed by the city in response to the Black Lives Matter protests of 2020. The remaining statue of Lee currently stands, but is covered with graffiti that has transformed it into an internationally recognized site of performance art for racial justice. And with this new court decision, it too is slated for removal.

Monument to Arthur Ashe Jr., Monument Avenue, Richmond, VA (front view).

For the first time in 130 years, a trip down Richmond’s Monument Avenue will not entail an involuntary Lost Cause pilgrimage. Rather—and this is the surprisingly moving experience I had biking down that street this past July—the empty pedestals will stand as silent indicting witnesses to the past valorization of white supremacy by a city’s white leaders and churches.

The monument to Arthur Ashe Jr. prominently incorporates a biblical inscription on the front of its pedestal.

“Since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us lay aside every weight, and the sin which so easily ensnares us, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us.” (Hebrews 12:1)

I don’t know everything Ashe and his family had in mind with that selection, but today it seems fitting for the last man standing on Monument Avenue.

Robert P. Jones, Ph.D., is the CEO and Founder of Public Religion Research Institute and is the author of White Too Long: The Legacy of White Supremacy in American Christianity and The End of White Christian America.This article was originally published on Robert P. Jones’s #WhiteTooLong substack. To read more and sign up, go to robertpjones.substack.com.

1 Karen L. Cox, No Common Ground: Confederate Monuments and the Ongoing Fight for Racial Justice (Chapel Hill, NC: The University of North Carolina Press, 2021), p. 45.

2 I tell the story of the 1907 unveiling of the monument to Jefferson Davis in White Too Long, pp. 107-112.

3 Ashe remains the only Black man to win the singles title at Wimbledon, the U.S. Open, and the Australian Open. He was the first black player selected to the U.S. Davis Cup team. To learn more about his remarkable life and legacy, see the 2019 New York Times notable book, Arthur Ashe: A Life, which chronicles his life not only on the court but also as an international civil rights activist and public intellectual.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s